Tag Archives: income

Navigating Bankruptcy Choices: Deciphering Chapter 7 vs. Chapter 13

Leave a reply

Introduction

For the person who is facing financial turmoil, the decision to file for bankruptcy is one fraught with complexity and nuance. Amidst the myriad considerations, understanding the distinctions between Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcy is paramount. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll unravel the intricacies of these two bankruptcy chapters, equipping you with the knowledge to make a well-informed decision tailored to your unique circumstances.

Chapter 7 Bankruptcy: The Liquidation Option

Chapter 7 bankruptcy, often referred to as “liquidation bankruptcy,” entails the liquidation of non-exempt assets to settle debts. This option is ideal for individuals seeking a fresh start without the burden of a repayment plan. People who are facing overwhelming debt may find Chapter 7 appealing for its expediency and potential for a swift resolution.

Determining Eligibility for Chapter 7

Individuals considering Chapter 7 must meet certain eligibility criteria, including passing the means test. This test evaluates your income relative to the median income in your state and determines your ability to repay debts. Understanding your eligibility is crucial in determining whether Chapter 7 is a viable option for your financial situation.

Pros and Cons of Chapter 7

  • Pros: Quick resolution, discharge of most unsecured debts, immediate relief from creditor harassment.
  • Cons: Potential loss of non-exempt assets, limited options for debt repayment, impact on credit score.

Chapter 13 Bankruptcy: The Repayment Solution

Chapter 13 bankruptcy, often termed “reorganization bankruptcy,” involves creating a structured repayment plan to settle debts over a period of three to five years. This option is suitable for people with a steady income who wish to retain their assets and repay debts over time in a manageable way.

Crafting a Repayment Plan:

In Chapter 13 bankruptcy, an experienced bankruptcy attorney will evaluate any non-exempt assets and their client’s income to help develop a feasible repayment plan. Some negotiation with the bankruptcy trustee may be involved. This plan outlines how debts will be repaid, typically prioritizing tax debts and secured debts while accommodating essential living expenses.

Pros and Cons of Chapter 13:

  • Pros: Protection of assets, opportunity to catch up on mortgage or car payments, potential to discharge certain debts upon completion of the repayment plan.
  • Cons: Lengthy process, strict adherence to repayment plan, potential for higher overall payments compared to Chapter 7.

Determining the Best Option

Sophisticated individuals evaluating bankruptcy options must conduct a thorough assessment of their financial situation, considering factors such as income, assets, debts, and long-term financial goals. Consulting with a knowledgeable bankruptcy attorney is invaluable in navigating the complexities of Chapter 7 and Chapter 13, as well as exploring alternative solutions.

Making an Informed Decision

Ultimately, the decision to file for Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy hinges on a careful evaluation of the benefits, drawbacks, and suitability of each option to your unique circumstances. Bankruptcy can be used as a strategic tool to regain financial stability and pave the way for a brighter financial future.

Conclusion

Navigating the choice between Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcy demands a nuanced understanding of each option’s implications. For the sophisticated individual, making an informed decision entails assessing eligibility, weighing the pros and cons, and aligning the chosen path with long-term financial objectives. With the guidance of a seasoned bankruptcy attorney, you can embark on the path towards financial recovery with clarity, confidence, and sophistication.

Schedule a free bankruptcy consultation with Jennifer Weil, a New Jersey bankruptcy attorney, to discuss your options.

Chapter 13 vs. Chapter 7 Bankruptcy: Key Differences

Leave a reply

Introduction

Facing financial challenges can be overwhelming, but understanding your options is the first step toward a fresh start. In this blog post, we’ll explore key aspects of Chapter 13 and Chapter 7 bankruptcy, shedding light on income considerations, the filing process, and the significance of proof of claim. If you’re considering bankruptcy, this guide is your compass through the intricate terrain of financial relief.

Chapter 13 Bankruptcy: A Tailored Repayment Plan

Chapter 13 bankruptcy is often referred to as the “wage earner’s plan.” It allows individuals with a regular income to create a structured repayment plan spanning three to five years. This plan considers your income, expenses, and debts, providing a realistic path to regain financial stability.

Understanding the Role of Income in Chapter 13

Chapter 13 bankruptcy hinges on your ability to propose a feasible repayment plan based on your income. Your attorney will work closely with you to determine the appropriate monthly payments to creditors, aiming for a fair distribution of your disposable income.

Chapter 7 Bankruptcy: A Fresh Start through Liquidation

In contrast, Chapter 7 bankruptcy involves liquidating non-exempt assets to pay off creditors. This form of bankruptcy is suitable for individuals with minimal income or those facing overwhelming debt that cannot be realistically repaid. Most people do not have any of their assets liquidated, since the law contains exemptions that protect these assets. A bankruptcy attorney can work with you to determine the best way to exempt your assets.

Navigating the Filing Process

When filing for bankruptcy, it’s crucial to understand the nuances of Chapter 13 and Chapter 7. Your attorney will guide you through the documentation process, helping you compile the necessary information for a successful filing.

Filing for bankruptcy requires comprehensive financial disclosures, including income details, assets, debts, taxes, and living expenses. You and your attorney should ensure accurate and thorough documentation, optimizing your chances of a successful bankruptcy discharge.

Proof of Claim: Securing Creditors’ Interests

In both Chapter 13 and Chapter 7 bankruptcy, creditors play a vital role in the process. A proof of claim is a document filed by creditors outlining the amount owed by the debtor. This document is crucial in determining how assets are distributed or how much is repaid in Chapter 13 bankruptcy.

The Importance of Proof of Claim

Creditors must file a proof of claim to be eligible for a share of any funds available for distribution. This document details the nature of the debt and the amount owed, ensuring transparency in the bankruptcy process.

Your bankruptcy attorney will closely scrutinize proof of claims to protect your interests, questioning any discrepancies and advocating for a fair distribution of available assets or funds.

Conclusion: A Stepping Stone to Financial Recovery

Navigating the complexities of Chapter 13 and Chapter 7 bankruptcy requires professional guidance. A skilled bankruptcy attorney can tailor a strategy based on your income, shepherd you through the filing process, and advocate for your interests during the proof of claim stage. If you’re considering bankruptcy, seize the opportunity for a fresh financial start with the support of experienced legal counsel.

Schedule a free bankruptcy consultation with Jennifer Weil, a New Jersey bankruptcy attorney, to discuss your options.

When Chapter 7s Are Not So Simple

Leave a reply

The goal of most Chapter 7 cases is to get in and get out—file the petition, go to a hearing with your attorney a month later, and two months after the hearing, your debts get written off. Mission accomplished, end of story. And usually that’s how it goes. What are some reasons that a Chapter 7 case doesn’t go that way?

Four main kinds of problems can happen:

Income

Under the “means test,” if you made or received too much money in the 6 full calendar months before your Chapter 7 case is filed, you can be disqualified from Chapter 7. As a result, you can be forced into a 3-to-5 year Chapter 13 case, or have your case be dismissed altogether. These results can be avoided by careful timing of your case filing, or by making changes to your income beforehand, or by a proactive filing under Chapter 13.

Assets

In Chapter 7, if you have an asset that is not “exempt” (protected), the Chapter 7 trustee will be entitled to take and sell that asset, and pay the proceeds to your creditors. You might be happy to surrender a particular asset you don’t need in return for the discharge of your debts, in particular if the trustee is going use the proceeds in part to pay a debt that you want paid, such as a child support arrearage or an income tax obligation. But you may not want to surrender that asset, either because you think it is worth less than the trustee thinks or because you believe it fits within an exemption. Or you may simply want to pay off the trustee for the privilege of keeping that asset. In all these “asset” scenarios, there are complications not present in an undisputed “no asset” case.

Creditor Challenges to Discharge of a Debt

Creditors have the limited right to raise objections to the discharge of their individual debts, on grounds such as fraud, misrepresentation, theft, intentional injury to person or property, and similar bad acts. In most circumstances, the creditor must raise such objections within about three months of the filing of your Chapter 7 case. So once that deadline passes you no longer need to worry about this, as long as that creditor got appropriate notice of your case.

Trustee Challenges to Discharge of Any Debts

If you do not disclose all your assets or fail to answer other questions accurately, either in writing or orally at the hearing with the trustee, or if you fail to cooperate with the trustee’s investigation of your financial circumstances, you could lose the ability to discharge any of your debts. The bankruptcy system relies on the honesty and accuracy of debtors. So the system is quite harsh toward those who abuse the system by trying to hide things.

To repeat: most of the time, Chapter 7s are straightforward. That’s especially true if you have been completely honest and thorough with your attorney during your meetings and through the information and documents you’ve provided. In Chapter 7 cases that I do for my clients, my job is to have those cases run smoothly. I do that by carefully reviewing my clients’ circumstances to make sure that there is nothing troublesome, and if there is, to address it in advance in the best way possible. That way we will have a smooth case, or at least my clients will know in advance the risks involved. So, be honest and thorough with your attorney, to increase the odds of having a simple Chapter 7 case.

Discuss your financial situation with bankruptcy attorney Jennifer N. Weil by scheduling a phone appointment at (201) 676-0722 or by emailing weilattorney@gmail.com.

2 Ways to Use Bankruptcy To Close Your Business

Leave a reply

2 ways to use bankruptcy to close your business involves leaving your business debt behind so that it does not come back to haunt you personally.

Closing down a business can be messy. Business bankruptcy is often more complicated than a regular bankruptcy case. But in one way, a business bankruptcy may be easier than a consumer bankruptcy case.

If you’ve owned a small business that you have shut down, or that you are about to shut down, you may be afraid of filing bankruptcy because you’ve heard that “business bankruptcies” are expensive and not a good way to wrap up the affairs of a business. However, bankruptcy can be a simple and effective solution.

The Means Test

The “means test” determines whether you may file a regular Chapter 7 case to discharge your debts in a few months, or whether you must file a 3-to-5-year Chapter 13 repayment case. Unless you need some of the other benefits of Chapter 13, many people prefer Chapter 7 because it gets them a fresh start more quickly and cheaply.

In some situations, a former business owner cannot pass the means test and will be required to go through Chapter 13. For example:

    • If, after closing her business, a business owner got a good job before filing bankruptcy, the income from that job may be higher than the “median income” applicable to her state and family size. So she may not pass the “means test.”
    • If the business was operated by one spouse while the other worked an outside job and earned a high income, the other spouse’s income may bump the couple above the “median income” with the result of not passing the “means test.”

But here’s the good news for some former business owners: the “means test” only applies if your “debts are primarily consumer debts.” (See Section 707(b)(1) of the Bankruptcy Code.) So if your debts are primarily business debts—more than 50%–you essentially can skip the “means test.”

Be careful here, because “debts” means all debts, including home mortgages and personal vehicle loans. So your business debts may have to be high to be more than all your consumer debts.

To apply this law, we must be clear about the difference between these two types of debts. What’s a “consumer debt”? The definition may sound familiar: it’s a “debt incurred by an individual primarily for a personal, family, or household purpose.” (Section 101(8).)  For example, if you took out a second mortgage on your home a few years ago to fund your business, the current balance on that second mortgage may not be a consumer debt.

Sometimes the line between consumer and non-consumer debt is not clear, so this is something you need to discuss thoroughly with your attorney if you want to avoid the “means test” under this “primarily business debts” exception.

If you have questions about qualifying for bankruptcy, call to schedule a free telephone appointment with Jennifer N. Weil, Esq. to discuss your situation at (201) 676-0722 or by emailing weilattorney@gmail.com.

Why Bankruptcy Means Test Timing Is Critical

Leave a reply

Waiting just one day to file your Chapter 7 bankruptcy case can make qualifying for it much easier—or much harder!

How could a small delay make such a big difference?

One of the goals behind the change in bankruptcy law in 2005 was to force more people to pay a portion of their debts through Chapter 13 payment plans instead of writing them off in Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy.” And the primary tool for this is the means test. The rationale behind the means test was to have a financial test that would find out who had the “means” to pay something to their creditors in Chapter 13.

But rules can have unintended consequences. An experienced lawyer will work to turn these consequences to your advantage.

Why bankruptcy means test timing is critical

The means test compares the income you received during the six FULL CALENDAR months before filing bankruptcy to the median income for your state and family size. If your income is at or under the median income, then you can file a Chapter 7 (except in unusual circumstances, which I’m not going to get into here). If your income is higher than the median, you may be able to file a Chapter 7, but you have to jump through hoops to do so. And there’s a risk that you will be forced to go through a Chapter 13 payment plan.  Having income below the median income amount makes your case less risky.

But how can filing the case a day earlier or later matter so much? Because of the means test’s fixation on those six full calendar months. And because the means test includes ALL income during that period (other than Social Security).  All of the money that comes into your hands during that period is counted, not just taxable income.

Imagine that you received a chunk of money, say a tax refund, a few catch-up child support payments, or an insurance settlement or reimbursement.  Not a huge amount, say $3,000, received on July 15 of last year. Your only other income is from your job, where make a $42,000 salary, or $3,500 gross per month. Let’s say that the median annual income for your state and family size is $43,000 (this is just an example – the median income for New Jersey is much higher, thank goodness).

Now we’re getting close to the end of January, your Chapter 7 bankruptcy paperwork is ready to file, and you’re anxious to get it filed. BUT, if your case is filed on or before January 31, then the last six full calendar month period will be from July 1 through December 31 of last year, which includes that $3,000 you received in mid-July. Your work income of 6 times $3,500 equals $21,000, plus that $3,000 totals $24,000 received during that 6-month period. Multiply that by 2 to make that an annual amount, and that equals $48,000, higher than the $42,000 median income. So you’d have failed the income portion of the means test.

But if you just wait to file until February 1, the applicable 6-month period jumps forward by 1 month to the period from August 1 of last year through January 31 of this year. That new period does NOT include the $3,000 you received in mid-July. Now your income during the 6-month period is $21,000, multiplied by 2 is $42,000. You would be under the $43,000 median income. You’ve passed the income portion of the means test, and you can skip the awkward and risky expenses part of the means test. You’re more likely to breeze through your Chapter 7 case.

Last thing: what if that $3,000 was not received almost 6 months ago, but rather 2 or 3 months ago, and you’re desperate to file your case? You need to stop a garnishment or foreclosure and you can’t wait another few months to file. If you file now, you will be over the median income, and you will need to do the expenses part of the means test. You may be OK there. But careful pre-bankruptcy planning is critical. The sooner we start, the more likely time will be on your side.

Are you eligible for Ch. 7 or Ch. 13 bankruptcy?

Leave a reply

Eligibility for Ch. 7 or Ch. 13 bankruptcy can turn on who is filing the bankruptcy, the type and amount of debt, the amount of income, and the amount of expenses.

Who is filing the bankruptcy:

Only a human being (or a human being and his or her spouse) can file a Chapter 13 case. Neither a partnership nor a corporation can file a Chapter 13 case, but it can file a Chapter 7, whether or not the business owner also files one individually.

The type and amount of debt:

If your debt is primarily consumer debt (a dollar amount of more than 50%), then you have to pass the means test to qualify for a Chapter 7. Under Chapter 7, there is no restriction on the amount of debt you can have in order to qualify. But, Chapter 13 is restricted to cases where the person filing has a maximum of $383,175 in total unsecured debt and $1,149,525 in total secured debt.

Amount of income:

If your income is no more than the median income for your family size and state, then you can easily pass the means test to qualify for a Ch. 7. Chapter 13 requires regular income, which the Bankruptcy Code defines as income that is “sufficiently stable and regular” to enable you to “make payments under a [Chapter 13] plan.” This makes sense because you will be making regular monthly payments for the duration of your Ch. 13 case. A Ch. 13 case will last three years if the income is less than the median income applicable to your family size and state; if the income is at the applicable median income amount or more, the Ch. 13 case will last five years.

The amount of expenses:

In Ch. 7, if your income is not below the median for your state, then you must complete a highly technical test involving some, but not necessarily all, of your expenses to see whether you pass the means test and thus whether you are eligible for a Ch. 7. In Ch. 13, a similar, but often more complicated, calculation largely determines the amount you must pay monthly into your plan to satisfy the requirements of Ch. 13.

Choosing between Ch. 7 and 13 can be simple. But there are at least a dozen major differences among them, differences of which you may not be aware. So when you come in to see me or another attorney, be clear about your goals but also be open-minded about how to reach them. You may well have tools available that you didn’t know about.

For bankruptcy in Northern New Jersey, call: (201) 676-0722 or schedule a consultation at my Setmore page.

Slight median income changes coming Nov. 1

Leave a reply


In New Jersey, it will be a little easier or a little harder to qualify for a Chapter 7 as of November 1, 2011. Whether it’ll be easier or harder for you depends on your family size.

The bankruptcy system looks to the U.S. Census to calculate each state’s median income, as applied to family size. If your income is below your state’s median income for your family size, then in most situations you would be eligible for a Chapter 7. But if your income is above the median and you still want to file a Chapter 7 case, then you have to fill out a long and rather complicated form detailing your allowed expenses to determine whether or not your filing of a Chapter 7 would be “abusive.” So if you want to file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, it’s a lot easier if you’re below the median.

On November 1, new median income amounts become applicable. In New Jersey, for a household of 1, the median income level will rise slightly from $59,060 to $60,322.  For a household of 2, it will drop from $70, 680 to $67, 503.  The new figures for all states can be seen here. Remember, if the median income goes up, that makes it a little more likely that your income will fall below that median, and you’ll have smoother sailing qualifying for Chapter 7.  New Jersey has some of the highest median income levels in the U.S.

So, if your income is close to the applicable median amount, and the median is increasing for your family size in your state on November 1, then you have a better chance at falling under the median if you file on or after that date.

Please understand that the meaning of “income” in the bankruptcy context is different from conventional meanings of that word. Bankruptcy “income” is calculated using a six-calendar-month look-back period that is doubled and then divided by 12 for an average monthly income. It includes all sources of income from all family members other than social security and does not only include taxable income.

Because of this and many other complicated issues, you should consult with a bankruptcy attorney about median income questions.

Photo by Rafa.Garcés.

Tip income can’t necessarily be garnished in New Jersey

Leave a reply

I have to admit, I picked this case for this post mainly because of its cool name, Big M, Inc. t/a Annie Sez v. Texas Roadhouse Holding, LLC. But it also has something interesting to say about debt collection.

The New Jersey Supreme Court decided Big M on July 16, 2010. The issue in the case was whether tips and gratuities are subject to garnishment. As you may recall, a garnishment can happen when a debt collector who has a judgment against you gets a court order to take part of your pay to satisfy the judgment.

Big M involved a waitress working for Texas Roadhouse Holding, LLC whose wages were being garnished. When her creditor, Big M, got a check for only $4.21 from its $672 wage garnishment, it sued her employer. In the course of deciding the case, the trial court judge determined that tips placed on credit cards are garnishable, but cash tips are not. Then the New Jersey Supreme Court considered the case on appeal.

Looking at both New Jersey law and the Federal Consumer Credit Protection Act (CCPA), the court did not find any law directly speaking to the issue of whether tips were subject to garnishment. So it examined an opinion letter and field operations handbook from the Department of Labor, which enforces the CCPA, and found the opinion that tips, whether paid in cash or charged, are not subject to garnishment. Although the New Jersey Supreme Court is not required to follow a Department of Labor opinion, the court chose to give the opinion consideration and deference.

Big M, the creditor, argued that all tips should be subject to garnishment because they are taxable income for state and federal tax purposes. The court did not find this argument persuasive because the process of counting and recording tip income and reporting it for tax purposes does not allow the employer to exercise enough control over tip income to make it garnishable. The whole idea behind wage garnishment is to capture the income while it is still in the employer’s hands, before it gets paid to the employee.

The court held that the amount of control an employer exercises over tip income determines whether those tips are subject to wage garnishment. If the employer pools all the tips and then divides the pooled amount amongst the employees, then tip income could be garnished. But if the tips are generally paid directly to the employee, even if the tips are charged on a credit card, they are not subject to garnishment.

Photo by respres.

Variable income and the Chapter 7 means test

Leave a reply

In qualifying for a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, means testing is not an issue for people whose pay is below the median for their state and family size, but for those whose income is more, it can be a problem.

The means test is like a big IRS form with spaces for plugging in certain numbers and checking off boxes. If you’ve filed for bankruptcy in years past, you may not have seen it. The form was introduced as a result of the new bankruptcy legislation that Congress passed in 2005, which created more hoops for individual bankruptcy filers to jump through.

It has two main parts: The first determines whether your earnings are above or below median. The second is for those who are above median – it lets you take *certain* deductions from your income in an attempt to lower it to the point where you can qualify for a Chapter 7.

Obviously, it’s preferable not to have to fill out the second part of the Chapter 7 means test.

Those whose earnings vary during the year might be in a better position with regard to the means test than those with steady over-median earnings. Examples of people with variable pay over the course of a typical year include teachers, college professors, those who work solely or primarily on commission, and those who periodically claim unemployment insurance benefits because of temporary jobs or seasonal employment.

Many people credit their variable income for getting them into debt trouble to begin with, since they aren’t always able to afford their monthly payments steadily throughout the year.

How can earnings that vary over the year possibly be to your benefit? Because the means test only includes the earnings you received during the 6 months before your bankruptcy filing. If that prior 6 months encompasses a part of the year during which your income was lower, you have a better chance at your pay being below the median and qualifying for a Chapter 7.

So when considering the question of when you should file, think about filing soon after a period of lower income.

Photo by Anonymous9000.